U.S. Military VeteranServing Tampa Bay 727-605-4433 [email protected]

Pinellas County · Gulf Beaches · Tampa Bay

Treasure Island, Florida Real Estate

A small barrier-island city with more than three miles of wide Gulf beach, canals and bay water on the other side, and St. Petersburg just across its own causeway — beach living that still feels like a neighbourhood, not a resort strip. This is Treasure Island through a local agent's eyes: what it feels like to live here, what the numbers actually say, and how to buy or sell well here.

Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty

Living in Treasure Island

Why people choose Treasure Island

Treasure Island is an incorporated city on a barrier island in Pinellas County — the Gulf of Mexico to the west, Boca Ciega Bay to the east. Madeira Beach and John's Pass sit at its northern end, St. Pete Beach lies to the south, and the Treasure Island Causeway connects the island directly to St. Petersburg. With 6,584 residents at the 2020 Census, it stays small and residential even as the beach draws visitors year-round.

Three beaches, one island

The shoreline runs more than three miles in three distinct stretches:

  • Sunshine Beach — the wide, quieter northern end
  • Mid-Island — the classic central beach behind Gulf Boulevard's hotels, shops and restaurants
  • Sunset Beach — the residential southern tip, with its boardwalk and pavilion

Gulf Boulevard (SR-699) runs the length of the island, so the beach, dining and everyday stops are never far from home.

Water on both sides

Turn away from the Gulf and Treasure Island is a boating city. Canal-front neighbourhoods such as Paradise Island put docks and lifts behind single-family homes, Boca Ciega Bay opens to the Intracoastal Waterway, and John's Pass at the island's northern tip connects the bay to the open Gulf — with its charter-fishing fleet, boat rentals and waterfront boardwalk just over the bridge in Madeira Beach.

Island life, city access

Treasure Island keeps its own mayor, city commission and municipal services — it has been one city since 1955, when the towns of Treasure Island, Boca Ciega, Sunshine Beach and Sunset Beach voted to consolidate. Day to day that means a small-town feel with real services, and downtown St. Petersburg's museums, dining and waterfront parks are a short drive east across the causeway.

Gulf-front beachesCanal-front & bay-front homesJohn's Pass boating accessSunset Beach boardwalkTreasure Island Causeway to St. Petersburg

Treasure Island Housing Market

What the numbers say — sourced

Treasure Island numbers swing more than most Tampa Bay markets, because a small island mixes condos, canal-front homes and Gulf-front estates in the same median — and a handful of high-end sales can move it. Here are the figures with their sources and dates attached.

About $620,000Median sale price — Treasure Island

Treasure Island's median sale price was about $620,000 in August 2026, down about 7% year over year. That figure mixes condos with single-family homes, which is why it sits well below what waterfront single-family homes trade for.

Source: Redfin, August 2026.

128 daysMedian days on market

Homes took a median of 128 days to sell in August 2026, and sellers received about 95% of their asking price on average — a market where buyers have time and negotiating room that did not exist in 2021–2022.

Source: Redfin, August 2026.

About $515,000Typical home value — ZIP 33740 area

Zillow's typical home value for the Treasure Island ZIP code area was about $515,000 at the end of January 2026. A typical-value index and a median sale price measure different things — expect them to differ, especially on an island with this much price spread.

Source: Zillow, January 2026.

In plain terms: where a Treasure Island home sits matters more than the island-wide median. Gulf-front, canal-front with a dock, elevated newer construction, and condo buildings each trade in their own range — and flood zone, elevation and insurance cost move the real monthly number as much as the price does. For a current, address-specific read, ask Brian for a fresh comparable-sales review rather than relying on any single headline figure.

Brian's Results in Treasure Island

Recent work on the island

Brian lists and sells on Treasure Island itself — from luxury waterfront listings to buyer purchases in the island's condo communities.

840 123rd Ave — Listed by Brian

$2,999,995 · MLS TB8559069

A 0.37-acre waterfront property with 240 feet of waterfront on Treasure Island — the kind of lot size and water frontage that rarely comes available on this island.

Ask Brian about this listing →

108 Sun Isle Cir #12 — Buyer Purchase

$435,000 · Sold September 19, 2024

Brian helped the buyer purchase this Treasure Island home for $435,000 — local guidance on island pricing, flood and insurance questions, and condo due diligence from contract to closing.

Talk to Brian about buying on the island →

Treasure Island Neighborhoods

Neighborhoods of Treasure Island

Treasure Island is one small city, but its neighborhoods feel very different from one another — the quiet south end, the resort center, the canal fingers on the bay side. The City of Treasure Island names five neighborhoods in its own resident guide — Sunshine Beach, Sunset Beach, Isle of Capri, Isle of Palms and Paradise Island — and the central beach district, Mid-Island, is the island's third main beach area. Each one below has its own page, with the market numbers and the flood, seawall and insurance checks that matter there.

Sunset Beach

The southern tip — the island's most residential beach, older cottages beside new elevated homes, a mile-long boardwalk and the Sunset Beach Pavilion.

Explore Sunset Beach →

Sunshine Beach

The north end — Gulf-front condos and beach homes steps from John's Pass and its boardwalk village.

Explore Sunshine Beach →

Mid-Island

The classic center — Gulf Front Park, Municipal Beach, and the resort strip along Gulf Boulevard.

Explore Mid-Island →

Isle of Capri

The northernmost finger island — canal homes with docks, minutes by water from John's Pass, including the Capri Isle bay-side section.

Explore Isle of Capri →

Paradise Island

A canal community of about 447 homes — docks, Treasure Bay Golf and Tennis, and a settled, owner-occupied feel.

Explore Paradise Island →

Isle of Palms

A bay-side canal neighborhood just south of the causeway — single-family homes with docks on Boca Ciega Bay, minutes from St. Petersburg.

Explore Isle of Palms →

Also part of the island, without a standalone page: Capri Isle — the bay-side section of Isle of Capri (Capri Boulevard and 123rd Avenue), covered on the Isle of Capri page; Key Capri — a gated waterfront condo community at 1 Key Capri on Isle of Capri, not a neighborhood, covered on the Isle of Capri page; Herrons Subdivision (Herron's Sub No. 1) — a platted subdivision name in the mid-island area near 95th Avenue, with no published community facts or neighborhood-level market data; Coney Island — a historical name, the site of Treasure Island's first hotel in 1915, not a current neighborhood; Mansions by the Sea — a single condo building at 7600 Bayshore Drive in Sunset Beach, not a neighborhood, mentioned on the Sunset Beach page.

Buying in Treasure Island

Buy well on the island

On a barrier island, the checks that matter go well beyond the house itself. Start with the real monthly number — then verify the water, the flood zone and the building.

Before you offer

  • Get pre-approved first and run the real monthly payment, including taxes, wind and flood insurance, and HOA or condo fees.
  • Check the flood zone by address. Most of Treasure Island sits in FEMA flood zones, and whether flood insurance is required — and what it costs — is property-specific. Never assume from the street name.
  • Price insurance early. Elevation, roof age and construction type drive coastal quotes. Get a real quote on a specific home before your inspection period runs out.
  • For condos, read the building file. Ask about milestone inspections, reserves, special assessments and any post-storm repair status before you commit.

Gulf-front, canal-front or condo?

Each Treasure Island property type comes with its own cost profile:

  • Gulf-front: the beach at your door, with the highest insurance and maintenance exposure on the island.
  • Canal-front / bay-front: dock and lift access for boaters — check seawall condition, water depth and lift capacity.
  • Condos: the most accessible way into island life; the building's reserves, assessments and rental rules matter as much as the unit.
  • Elevation matters: homes built or rebuilt to current elevation standards generally insure differently than older ground-level homes.

Ask Brian for current Treasure Island listings →

Selling in Treasure Island

Sell for what island buyers pay for

Treasure Island buyers pay for water, beach access, elevation and condition — and in a market giving sellers about 95% of asking on average, pricing and presentation have to name those things plainly from day one.

Price from your stretch of the island

An island-wide median blends condos with Gulf-front estates. Price from recent sales of genuinely similar homes — same property type, similar water frontage, elevation and condition — then check how long those homes actually took to sell. Have your flood, elevation and insurance documentation ready early; island buyers and their lenders will ask, and surprises there slow closings.

Present what the island is sold on

  • Lead with the water: beach distance, canal frontage, dock and lift, and Gulf or bay views.
  • Put elevation, roof age and any post-storm repairs or upgrades up front — coastal buyers are insurance-sensitive and ask early.
  • Real photos of your real home, priced honestly from day one — overpricing into a balanced market costs more than it gains.

Get a Treasure Island home valuation →

Your Agent for the Gulf Beaches

Brian Baker works Treasure Island

Brian lists and sells on Treasure Island — including the $2,999,995 waterfront listing at 840 123rd Ave — and helps buyers across the Gulf Beaches and St. Petersburg. He has lived in the Tampa Bay area for over 15 years and brings nearly two decades in business operations to pricing, negotiation and closing.

Contact

Brian Baker, REALTOR®
Keller Williams St. Pete Realty
Arrivato Homes Group

Call 727-605-4433
[email protected]

Work with Brian

Buying, selling, waterfront and luxury property, VA loans, first-time buyers, and investment property across Treasure Island, St. Petersburg and Tampa Bay.

Contact page →

Explore other areas

Brian serves communities across Tampa Bay and western Pasco County. Compare them side by side:

St. Petersburg →  Tampa →  Palm Harbor →  Trinity →  Land O' Lakes →  Odessa →  Westchase →  New Port Richey →  Back to Homepage →

Contact

Thinking about a move in Treasure Island?

Tell Brian what you're trying to do — buy, sell, or just understand what your Treasure Island home is worth — and he'll give you the real numbers first.

Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty