Treasure Island · Pinellas County · Tampa Bay, Florida
The northernmost of Treasure Island's three connected islands — a quiet, canal-lined finger of bay-front homes, townhomes and condos, minutes by water from John's Pass and the Gulf.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Isle of Capri
Isle of Capri is the northernmost of Treasure Island's three connected barrier islands, reached by a short bridge off Gulf Boulevard. It is the island's boating neighborhood: canal homes with seawalls and docks on Boca Ciega Bay, bay views rather than direct Gulf frontage for most properties, and the pass and the open Gulf minutes away by water. The bay-side section is known as Capri Isle, and at its far end sits the gated Key Capri condo community overlooking John's Pass.
One way in, one way out. A single road leads onto Isle of Capri — over the bridge at 116th Avenue — and the island's streets are Capri Boulevard and the Capri Circles. That quiet is part of the appeal: a residential neighborhood, not a through-route, where many owners are long-term residents and snowbirds.
Built for boaters. Almost every home is waterfront, with a private dock behind it. Seawall condition, water depth and lift capacity matter more here than square footage — one October 2026 listing offered 75 feet of seawall, a private dock and a jet ski lift. From the canals, boaters reach Boca Ciega Bay, the Intracoastal Waterway, and the Gulf through John's Pass to the north or Blind Pass to the south.
Rosselli Park. The neighborhood park at the north end is a gathering spot — dog park meetups, tennis and pickleball, ball games and shuffleboard — and a short walk or bike ride from the island's homes.
Capri Isle and Key Capri. Capri Isle is the bay-side section — Capri Boulevard and 123rd Avenue — where cul-de-sac lots carry up to 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage. Key Capri, at 1 Key Capri, is a gated waterfront condo community on its own private island at the end, with a marina, heated pool and spa, fitness center and tennis, built in the 1970s.
What Isle of Capri Offers
These are the pieces of Isle of Capri that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell — and the ones buyers ask about first when they tour.
The neighborhood park at the north end — dog park, tennis and pickleball, a ball field and shuffleboard. A gathering spot for residents.
The pass and the Gulf are minutes by water from the island's docks — the quickest route from the bay to open water.
The bay-side section, where quiet cul-de-sacs carry up to 240 feet of Intracoastal frontage — including Brian's $2,999,995 listing at 840 123rd Ave.
A gated waterfront condo community at 1 Key Capri, on its own private island overlooking John's Pass — with its own marina, heated pool and spa, fitness center and tennis.
255 Capri Circle N — bay-side condos with three-bedroom plans of about 2,030 square feet.
Townhomes on Intracoastal and harbor frontage, built in the early 1980s — 67 townhomes reported, on three levels.
Housing Market
Isle of Capri figures below are neighborhood-specific, from 2026 sales and listings; the city-level figures are labeled as such. No Isle of Capri–specific days on market is published by the major portals.
Source: Sources: Rocks Realty, “Living in Treasure Island FL: 2026 Neighborhoods, Prices and Beach Life” (therocksrealty.com, figures as shown November 2026) for Isle of Capri figures; Redfin, August 2026 (Treasure Island city-level: median sale price about $620,000, down about 7% year over year; median 128 days on market; sellers received about 95% of asking price); Brian's 840 123rd Ave listing, MLS TB8559069, as listed on the Treasure Island area page. Condo medians are 12-month medians as shown November 2026.
What this means in plain terms: Isle of Capri spans the island's widest price range in one neighborhood — condos from about $190,000 at the lower end, canal homes up to about $1.85 million, and trophy lots like the 840 123rd Ave parcel at $2,999,995. The premium is water: dock, lift, seawall footage, and the minutes-to-the-pass route.
The seawall is the inspection. On a canal island, the seawall's age and condition matter as much as the roof. Treasure Island holds a Class 6 Community Rating System rating, which gives flood insurance policyholders a 20% discount, and new or rebuilt homes must sit 2 feet above the base flood elevation — but the quote is still property-specific, and the seawall is a real cost.
Buying in Isle of Capri
On a barrier island, the checks that matter go well beyond the house itself. Start with the real monthly number — then verify the water, the flood zone and the building.
Selling in Isle of Capri
Isle of Capri homes sell on the water and the neighborhood as much as on the house itself. The listings that move are priced against Isle of Capri — not against the island-wide median — and marketed to the buyer who wants this part of the island.
Brian's Take
Most buyers come to Isle of Capri because the neighborhood sells itself the minute you drive in. My job is to make sure the numbers — and the water, the seawall and the insurance — work as well as the feeling does.
Explore Treasure Island & Nearby Areas
Isle of Capri is one neighborhood on a small island — compare the island's other neighborhoods and the wider Tampa Bay area before you settle on one place.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Isle of Capri — the flood zone and insurance picture, the seawall and dock questions, and what homes in this neighborhood are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Isle of Capri, Treasure Island, St. Petersburg, Tampa, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]