Treasure Island · Pinellas County · Tampa Bay, Florida
The southern tip of Treasure Island — its most residential beach neighborhood, where older cottages sit beside new elevated homes, and the day ends around a mile-long boardwalk and the Sunset Beach Pavilion.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach sits at the southern tip of Treasure Island, Florida, where Gulf Boulevard meets the Blind Pass bridge to St. Pete Beach. It is one of the island's three main beach areas — alongside Sunshine Beach and Mid-Island — and it is the most residential of the three: single-family homes, smaller condominiums and duplexes, with a local-occupant character that sets it apart from the hotel-heavy stretches farther north.
A beach neighborhood, not a resort strip. Homes on record here date as far back as 1935, with a median build year in the 1940s — and many of those cottages are now being replaced with raised homes built to today's elevation rules. Only a few homes sell here each year, so every sale is a data point.
The boardwalk and the pavilion. A paved path about a mile long runs along the shoreline around the tip of the island — a favorite for walking, jogging, biking and watching the sun go down. The Sunset Beach Pavilion at 8000 W Gulf Boulevard holds restrooms, outdoor showers, a playground and a rental hall used for weddings and neighborhood events; it reopened June 4, 2026 after about $350,000 in repairs.
Water on two sides. The Gulf is to the west; Blind Pass and Boca Ciega Bay are to the east and south. From the southern end you can look directly across Blind Pass at Upham Beach in St. Pete Beach, and when the wind picks up this is one of the few Tampa Bay beaches where surfers show up.
The honest trade-off: flood zones AE and VE cover the neighborhood, and an older ground-level cottage insures very differently than a new elevated home. Few sales a year also means thin comparables — a Sunset Beach home is priced from the island and similar beach neighborhoods, not from a neighborhood median made of three sales.
What Sunset Beach Offers
These are the pieces of Sunset Beach that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell — and the ones buyers ask about first when they tour.
8000 W Gulf Boulevard — restrooms, outdoor showers, a playground and a rental hall for weddings and neighborhood events. It has served the neighborhood since 2003 and reopened June 4, 2026 after storm repairs.
About a mile of paved path around the island's tip, over the dunes — a favorite for walking, jogging, biking and watching the sun go down.
The pass at the southern tip, between Treasure Island and St. Pete Beach. Upham Beach is directly across the water.
7500 Bayshore Dr — 180 units in 10 four-story buildings on about 14 acres at the south tip, with Gulf and Blind Pass views.
7600 Bayshore Dr — Gulf-front condos with 1- and 2-bedroom units of about 1,000 to 1,550 square feet, steps from the sand.
Sunset Beach is one of the few beaches in the Tampa Bay region known for welcoming the LGBT community — and for a laid-back, local feel.
Housing Market
Sunset Beach is the priciest corner of Treasure Island — and the thinnest market. The figures below are Sunset Beach–specific, from 2026 sales and listings; the city-level figures are labeled as such.
Source: Sources: Rocks Realty, “Living in Treasure Island FL: 2026 Neighborhoods, Prices and Beach Life” (therocksrealty.com, figures as shown November 2026) for Sunset Beach figures; Redfin, August 2026 (Treasure Island city-level: median sale price about $620,000, down about 7% year over year; median 128 days on market; sellers received about 95% of asking price). With only three Sunset Beach sales in the 12 months through September 2026, one sale moves the median a lot — treat the $1.5 million median as a headline, not a price for a specific home.
What this means in plain terms: Sunset Beach at a $1.5 million 12-month median sits far above the Treasure Island median of about $620,000 — but it is a median built on three sales. The real story is the range: older cottages and smaller condos at the lower end, renovated and new elevated homes with Gulf or bay frontage at $1.5 million and up.
Elevation is the price. A raised home and a ground-level cottage on the same street can insure very differently. Treasure Island holds a Class 6 Community Rating System rating, which gives flood insurance policyholders a 20% discount, and new or rebuilt homes must sit 2 feet above the base flood elevation. The elevation certificate and a real flood quote belong in the price conversation, not after it.
Buying in Sunset Beach
On a barrier island, the checks that matter go well beyond the house itself. Start with the real monthly number — then verify the water, the flood zone and the building.
Selling in Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach homes sell on the water and the neighborhood as much as on the house itself. The listings that move are priced against Sunset Beach — not against the island-wide median — and marketed to the buyer who wants this part of the island.
Brian's Take
Most buyers come to Sunset Beach because the neighborhood sells itself the minute you drive in. My job is to make sure the numbers — and the water, the seawall and the insurance — work as well as the feeling does.
Explore Treasure Island & Nearby Areas
Sunset Beach is one neighborhood on a small island — compare the island's other neighborhoods and the wider Tampa Bay area before you settle on one place.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Sunset Beach — the flood zone and insurance picture, the seawall and dock questions, and what homes in this neighborhood are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Sunset Beach, Treasure Island, St. Petersburg, Tampa, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]