Trinity · Pasco County · Tampa Bay, Florida
A master-planned community on about 2,400 acres beside Jay B. Starkey Wilderness Park — with its own K-8 school, a neighborhood market, 20-plus miles of trails, and new construction still underway. Note: Starkey Ranch carries an Odessa mailing address (ZIP 33556) and sits directly east of Trinity along SR-54 — it is grouped with Trinity because that is how buyers search for it and how the Trinity area page presents it.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Starkey Ranch
Starkey Ranch is the largest active master-planned development in western Pasco County, along Trinity Boulevard and Gunn Highway off SR-54, bordering Jay B. Starkey Wilderness Park. Roughly half of its roughly 2,400 acres is kept as lakes, ponds, wetlands, and parks, and the county approved the community for up to 5,050 residences.
Trails are the backbone of daily life. The community was planned around a 20-mile trail system (some descriptions put it at 22 miles) that connects into the 42-mile Suncoast Trail, plus 150 acres of parks and an 80-acre district park with sports fields, playgrounds, walking trails, and a splash pad.
A school and a market inside the gates. Starkey Ranch K-8 — an A-rated school — sits inside the community, and the Starkey Market serves as a neighborhood market and gathering space. A Publix is also within the community, so a grocery run can be a walk or a golf-cart ride.
Named neighborhoods, different builders. Homes are grouped into named sections built by different builders — including Taylor Morrison, David Weekley Homes, Homes by WestBay, Cardel Homes, and Lennar — from townhomes in the $300,000s to large executive homes above $1.5 million. Esplanade is the gated, resort-style 55+ section by Taylor Morrison.
The honest trade-off: the CDD. Every Starkey Ranch home pays a Community Development District assessment on the property tax bill — roughly $2,300 to $3,400 a year depending on the section — plus a master association fee of about $75 a year and a neighborhood HOA that varies widely by section. Short-term rentals are restricted by the governing documents, so this is not an Airbnb play.
Amenities
The amenity list varies by section, but these are the pieces buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell.
An A-rated public K-8 school inside the community — one of the biggest reasons families choose Starkey Ranch over other new construction.
A planned trail network through the community connecting to the Suncoast Trail, plus the 8,000-plus-acre Jay B. Starkey Wilderness Park next door for hiking, biking, and horseback riding.
A neighborhood market and gathering space, plus a Publix inside the community — daily errands without getting on SR-54.
Sports fields, playgrounds, walking trails, and a splash pad in the community's district park, on top of 150 acres of parks community-wide.
Multiple community pools, playgrounds, athletic fields, a dog park, and a community garden across the neighborhoods.
A gated, resort-style 55+ section with its own private clubhouse; its higher HOA includes lawn care in many cases. A strong option for downsizers who want the Starkey Ranch lifestyle without the yard work.
Housing Market
Starkey Ranch is Trinity's premium new-construction market — its median runs well above Trinity as a whole. The figures below are Starkey Ranch-specific, from Realty.com's neighborhood table (April 2026) and a 2026 market report.
Sources: Realty.com — Trinity neighborhood tables, MLS GRID data as of April 3, 2026 (Starkey Ranch median list price $649,950; $248/sq ft; median year built 2020; median lot 6,319 sq ft); Rocks Realty, "Living in Starkey Ranch," September 2026 (median sale price about $678,000 in August 2026, down about 6% year over year; about 52 homes listed from a $360,000 townhome to a home near $1.57 million). Starkey Ranch-specific days on market is not published by the major portals — for context, the Trinity ZIP 34655 median was 72 days on market for active listings (Realtor.com, October 2026). Figures change monthly — contact Brian for current data.
What this means in plain terms: Starkey Ranch at a roughly $650,000–$678,000 median sits about $150,000–$180,000 above Trinity's overall median sale price near $499,000 — you are paying for new construction, the school, and the amenity package, and the market prices it that way. A median sale price down about 6% year over year in August 2026 says this is a moderating market, not a runaway one.
New construction is the competition — and the opportunity. Builder incentives can be real money here, but lot premiums and upgrades add up fast, and the CDD varies by section. Compare a new build and a resale on total monthly cost, not just list price — and bring your own agent to the builder's sales office, because it represents the builder.
Buying in Starkey Ranch
Starkey Ranch rewards buyers who check the full cost picture early. The list price is only part of what a home here costs each month — get the rest of the numbers before you fall in love with a floor plan.
Selling in Starkey Ranch
Starkey Ranch homes sell on the community as much as on the house itself. The listings that move are priced against Starkey Ranch — not against Trinity as a whole — and marketed to the buyer who wants this lifestyle.
Brian's Take
Most buyers come to Starkey Ranch because it feels like a finished town the minute you drive in — trails, the school, the market right there. My job is to make sure the numbers work as well as the feeling does.
Explore Nearby Areas
Starkey Ranch is one neighborhood inside Trinity — compare the other Trinity communities, and the wider area, before you settle on one.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Starkey Ranch — the HOA and any CDD costs, the new-build-versus-resale comparison where it applies, and what homes in your section are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Starkey Ranch, Trinity, Odessa, Land O'Lakes, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]