Trinity · Pasco County · Tampa Bay, Florida
A cozy 91-home Ryan Homes community beside J.W. Mitchell High School — low $25-a-month HOA, no CDD, and a playground and wetlands at the edge of Trinity.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Mitchell Ranch
Mitchell Ranch is a 91-site community in Trinity, at the intersection of Phototronics Court and Branding Iron Drive, just south of Mitchell Ranch Plaza and next door to J.W. Mitchell High School and Trinity Oaks Elementary. The primary builder is Ryan Homes, and the homes were built from about 2020 onward — making Mitchell Ranch one of Trinity's newest small communities.
Small on purpose. With only 91 homes, Mitchell Ranch is a quiet, friendly-feeling neighborhood — a playground and field, natural wetlands, and conservation lots at the edges, rather than a resort amenity package.
The number that defines Mitchell Ranch: $25 a month. The average HOA fee is about $25 a month, and there are no CDD fees — one of the lowest carrying costs among Trinity's newer communities, and the reason buyers who do the math keep coming back here.
Newer homes, practical sizes. Floor plans range from about 1,500 to 2,600 square feet, with three and four bedrooms, two full baths, and two-car garages — one and two stories — plus a townhome section, Mitchell Ranch 54 West, with a pool, playground, and walking areas.
Location that does the heavy lifting. Mitchell Ranch Plaza — with Walmart, Target, Sprouts, Publix, Chick-fil-A, and more — is next door, and the YMCA, Trinity's schools, and SR-54 are minutes away.
Amenities
The amenity list varies by section, but these are the pieces buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell.
Next door to J.W. Mitchell High School and Trinity Oaks Elementary — the school run is a walk, not a drive.
A community playground and field, plus natural wetlands and conservation lots at the edges.
About $25 a month in HOA dues and no CDD — one of the lowest carrying costs among Trinity's newer communities.
A townhome section with a community pool, playground, and walking areas.
Walmart, Target, Sprouts, Publix, Chick-fil-A, and more — next door, not across town.
Homes here are in Flood Zone X on many listings — no flood insurance required — but confirm for the specific property.
Housing Market
Mitchell Ranch is a small newer community — no neighborhood-level median is published by the major portals, so the figures below are the published broker range plus Trinity-level medians, clearly labeled.
Sources: nowtb.com, "Trinity FL Homes for Sale: Complete Buyer Guide," September 26, 2026 (Mitchell Ranch $400,000–$560,000); newhomefuture.com, November 2025 (Mitchell Ranch, 91 homes; HOA about $25 a month; no CDD; floor plans 1,500–2,600 sq ft; Ryan Homes); Stellar MLS listings, 2025–2026 (built 2020–2023; Trinity Elementary, Seven Springs Middle, J.W. Mitchell High); Homes.com, November 12, 2026 (Trinity average value $502K); Redfin, September 2026 (Trinity median sale price near $499,000); Realtor.com, October 2026 (ZIP 34655 median asking price $352,500; 72 days on market). Mitchell Ranch-specific median price and days-on-market figures are not published by the major portals. Figures change monthly — contact Brian for current data.
What this means in plain terms: Mitchell Ranch's $400,000–$560,000 range sits close to Trinity's overall median sale price near $499,000 — newer construction, a small community, and a low monthly number, without the CDD that Starkey Ranch carries. That combination is the value proposition here.
Small community, thin comparable sales. With only 91 homes, recent Mitchell Ranch sales are few — price from the most recent Mitchell Ranch sales and the closest comparable small communities, not from Trinity-wide figures.
Buying in Mitchell Ranch
Mitchell Ranch rewards buyers who check the exact home and the low monthly number early. The small-community feel sells itself — the comparable sales are where deals get priced.
Selling in Mitchell Ranch
Mitchell Ranch homes sell on newness, small-community feel, and the low monthly number. The listings that move price against Mitchell Ranch, not against Trinity as a whole.
Brian's Take
Most buyers come to Mitchell Ranch because it is the small, new Trinity community with the low monthly number — 91 homes, $25 a month, no CDD, and the high school next door. My job is to make sure the comparable sales back up the price.
Explore Nearby Areas
Mitchell Ranch is one neighborhood inside Trinity — compare the other Trinity communities, and the wider area, before you settle on one.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Mitchell Ranch — the HOA and any CDD costs, the new-build-versus-resale comparison where it applies, and what homes in your section are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Mitchell Ranch, Trinity, Odessa, Land O'Lakes, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]