Odessa · Pasco County · Tampa Bay, Florida
An exclusive 24-hour guard-gated estate community — only 48 homesites across 114-plus acres of conservation and lakes, with custom Mediterranean estates.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Stillwater
Stillwater is an exclusive 24-hour guard-gated community in Odessa with only 48 estate homesites across 114-plus acres of conservation and lakes. Custom-built estates — Mediterranean-style homes of 5,000-plus square feet on 1.5- to 3.75-acre homesites — sit in dense forest with resort-style outdoor living: heated saltwater pools and spas, covered patios with outdoor kitchens, and combined tennis, pickleball, and basketball courts.
Forty-eight homesites, 114-plus acres. The math is the story: fewer than fifty homesites across more than 114 acres of conservation and lakes. Privacy here is structural — the land itself is the amenity.
Custom estates, resort outdoors. Homes here are custom-built — a 5,696-square-foot, 5-bedroom, 7-bath Mediterranean estate on 3.75 private acres, and a 5,630-square-foot custom home by Fechtel on 1.5 private acres, are representative. Heated infinity pools and spas, gas fire pits, stone pavers, archway-covered terraces, full summer kitchens, and separate pool baths are standard at this level.
Guard-gated, 24 hours. Stillwater is protected with 24-hour guard-gated security — the highest level of controlled access in Odessa, and part of what buyers at this price point expect.
The honest trade-off: Stillwater is the most expensive resale market in this inventory, with a $2,100,000 median sale price over the past year. Estate acreage carries estate costs, and a 48-homesite community means a very thin comparable set.
Amenities
The amenity list is long, but these are the pieces buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell.
Protected with 24-hour guard-gated security — the highest level of controlled access in Odessa.
Only 48 estate homesites across 114-plus acres of conservation and lakes.
Custom-built estates of 5,000-plus square feet on 1.5- to 3.75-acre homesites.
Heated saltwater pools and spas, covered patios with outdoor kitchens, and tennis/pickleball and basketball courts.
Dense forest and conservation views that give every estate a private, natural setting.
In the heart of Odessa, minutes from top-rated schools, hospitals, dining, shopping, major highways, and Tampa International Airport.
Housing Market
Stillwater is the most expensive resale market in this inventory — a $2,100,000 median sale price over the past year, in a community of just 48 homesites.
Sources: Homes by Marco — Odessa subdivisions, as shown November 12, 2026; Smith & Associates listing for 7713 Still Lakes Dr (sold August 26, 2025). No neighborhood-level days-on-market figure is published for Stillwater; for context, Odessa overall averaged 63 days on market (Homes.com, as shown November 2026). For context, Odessa overall showed a $725,000 median sale price and 63 days on market (Homes.com, as shown November 2026), and a $728,225 median listing price with a $741,850 median sold price (Realtor.com market trends, October 2026).
What this means in plain terms: three sales in the past year at $2,000,000 to $2,660,000, with a $2,100,000 median, put Stillwater at nearly three times the Odessa town-wide median of $725,000. You are paying for the gate, the acreage, the conservation setting, and the scarcity — 48 homesites in all of Tampa Bay.
Thin comps cut both ways. With three sales in a year, each listing is priced on its own merits — lot size, condition, and outdoor living. Buyers should expect a pricing opinion built on genuinely similar Odessa estate sales, not on a neighborhood median built from three data points.
Buying in Stillwater
Buying in Stillwater means buying at the top of the Odessa market — pre-approval, a clear budget, and a pricing opinion built on real estate comps, not on a median.
Selling in Stillwater
Stillwater homes sell on scarcity and setting. The estates that move are priced against real Odessa estate comps and marketed on what cannot be duplicated — the gate, the acreage, and the conservation.
Brian's Take
Stillwater is the community I mention to buyers who want the most private, most guarded version of Odessa — 48 homesites, 114 acres of conservation, and a gate that never sleeps.
Explore More Odessa Neighborhoods
Stillwater is one community inside Odessa — compare the wider area before you settle on one neighborhood.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Stillwater — the HOA and CDD costs, the new-build-versus-resale comparison, and what homes in your section are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Stillwater, Odessa, Trinity, Land O'Lakes, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]