U.S. Military VeteranServing Tampa Bay 727-605-4433 [email protected]

Tampa · Hillsborough County · Tampa Bay, Florida

Old Seminole Heights Tampa, Florida

The oldest section of Seminole Heights, with the Hillsborough River on its west side — Craftsman bungalows, brick streets, and the neighborhood association that says it is the city's largest. If you are buying or selling in Old Seminole Heights, start with a local who knows the area block by block.

Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413

Home  ›  Tampa  ›  Old Seminole Heights

Living in Old Seminole Heights

The Original Seminole Heights, on the River

Old Seminole Heights is the oldest and westernmost section of Seminole Heights, with the Hillsborough River running along its west side. It holds the core of the Seminole Heights Historic District (National Register 1993, local district 1995) and the neighborhood's most established bungalow streets.

The river is the edge. The Hillsborough River runs along the west side of Old Seminole Heights, giving the neighborhood a green corridor and a natural boundary that the rest of Seminole Heights does not have.

The association is the community. The Old Seminole Heights Neighborhood Association says it is the city's largest, with 500+ members — a sign of how organized and active this part of the neighborhood is.

Craftsman bungalows, a century old. The housing stock is early-1900s bungalows on brick streets with mature trees. That character is the draw, and it means repair and upgrade costs, and historic-district rules on exterior work, are part of owning here.

The honest trade-off: Old Seminole Heights is the most established — and usually the most expensive — part of Seminole Heights. Buyers who want the river and the oldest streets pay for them; buyers who want the lowest entry price in the area will find it further south or east.

What Old Seminole Heights Offers

What Old Seminole Heights Residents Actually Use Every Week

The pieces buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell.

Hillsborough River

The river runs along the neighborhood's west side — a green corridor close to downtown.

Historic District Core

The core of the Seminole Heights Historic District: National Register 1993, local district 1995.

Largest Neighborhood Association

The Old Seminole Heights Neighborhood Association says it is the city's largest, with 500+ members.

Craftsman Bungalows

Early-1900s bungalows on brick streets with mature oaks — the neighborhood's signature housing.

Florida Avenue Nearby

The restaurant and brewpub scene along Florida Avenue is the neighborhood's main street, a short drive east.

Close to Downtown

About 3 miles north of downtown Tampa — a short commute to the office and the Riverwalk.

Housing Market

The Old Seminole Heights Housing Market

No neighborhood-level market figures are published for Old Seminole Heights by the major portals. Read it against its parent market: Seminole Heights' ZIP-level median home values were $391,000 (33603) and $311,900 (33604) in the U.S. Census ACS 2020–2024, and the figures below are Tampa city-level, clearly labeled as such.

$460,000Median home price, Tampa — Homes.com, November 2026
$437,500Median sale price, Tampa — Homes.com, November 2026, +4% year over year
$319Average price per square foot, Tampa — Homes.com, November 2026
3,987Active listings in Tampa — Homes.com, November 2026; about 5 months of supply, a balanced market
71 daysMedian days on market, Tampa — Realtor.com, October 2026

Source: No neighborhood-level market figures are published for Old Seminole Heights by the major portals. The figures above are city-level Tampa figures, clearly labeled as such: Homes.com, November 2026 — median home price $460,000, median sale price $437,500 (+4% year over year), $319 per square foot, 3,987 active listings, about 5 months of supply (a balanced market); Realtor.com, October 2026 — median listing price $440,000, median sold price $415,000, $280 per square foot, and a median of 71 days on market. Neighborhood-level days on market is not published for Old Seminole Heights; the 71-day figure above is the Tampa citywide median. Figures change monthly and vary sharply by street and property type — ask Brian for a current comparable-sales report for a specific home in Old Seminole Heights.

What this means in plain terms: Old Seminole Heights is the premium section of Seminole Heights — the oldest streets, the river edge, and the strongest association. Expect it to trade above the Seminole Heights ZIP medians, while still sitting well below South Tampa prices.

Block by block is real here. Prices vary sharply within Seminole Heights, and the ZIP medians cover a wide range. A current comparable-sales report for the specific block is the only reliable pricing tool in Old Seminole Heights.

Buying in Old Seminole Heights

Buying a Home in Old Seminole Heights

Old Seminole Heights rewards buyers who check the full picture early. The list price is only part of what a home here costs each month — get the rest of the numbers before you fall in love with a floor plan.

Start Your Old Seminole Heights Search

Selling in Old Seminole Heights

Selling a Home in Old Seminole Heights

Homes in Old Seminole Heights sell on the neighborhood as much as on the house itself. The listings that move are priced against Old Seminole Heights — not against Tampa as a whole — and marketed to the buyer who wants this lifestyle.

Get a Home Value Conversation

Brian's Take

What I Tell Old Seminole Heights Buyers Before We Tour a Single Home

Most buyers come here because the neighborhood sells itself the minute you drive in. My job is to make sure the numbers work as well as the feeling does.

Explore Nearby Areas

Explore Nearby Areas

Old Seminole Heights is one neighborhood inside Tampa — compare the wider city before you settle on one community.

Talk to Brian

Buying or Selling in Old Seminole Heights?

Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Old Seminole Heights — what homes in your section are actually selling for, and what to check before you offer. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Old Seminole Heights, Tampa, St. Petersburg, and the wider Tampa Bay area.

Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]