U.S. Military VeteranServing Tampa Bay 727-605-4433 [email protected]

Land O'Lakes · Pasco County · Tampa Bay, Florida

Bexley Land O'Lakes, Florida

A master-planned community built around 1,200 acres of preserved Florida wilderness — with resort-style amenities, its own elementary school, and a town-center-style Hub at the entrance. If you are buying or selling in Bexley, start with a local who knows Land O'Lakes block by block.

Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413

Home  ›  Land O'Lakes  ›  Bexley

Living in Bexley

A Community Built Around the Land, Not Over It

Bexley is a master-planned community by Newland (now Brookfield) in Land O'Lakes, off State Road 54 between the Suncoast Parkway and US-41, in ZIP code 34638. It covers 1,834 acres — and 1,200 of those acres are preserved natural wilderness, woven through the neighborhood with trails, ponds, and tree-lined streets.

Trails and open space are the setting, not an afterthought. More than 10 miles of multi-use trails wind through the community and connect to the Suncoast Trail, so a bike ride or a morning walk starts at your front door. The preserve land is part of daily life here — ponds, wooded buffers, and wildlife between the villages.

A neighborhood with its own school and its own main street. Bexley Elementary School opened inside the community in 2017, and older students go on to Charles S. Rushe Middle School and Sunlake High School. At the entrance, The Hub at Bexley — opened in 2022 — brings dining, coffee, shops, fitness, and coworking to the neighborhood, with a Friday Moonlight Market on the second and fourth Fridays.

Three ways to live here. Bexley South and Bexley North hold the main single-family neighborhoods, with townhomes and villas for lower-maintenance living. Del Webb Bexley is a separate gated 55+ section with its own amenity package — its HOA includes cable, internet, and lawn maintenance. Builders across the community have included David Weekley Homes, Del Webb, and Lennar, with most homes built from 2016 onward.

The honest trade-off: Bexley runs on a Community Development District (CDD) plus HOA dues. The CDD is a line item on the annual property tax bill, not a separate bill — about $2,539 a year on recent listings — and it does add real cost. Buyers who budget for the full carrying cost up front love it here; buyers who only compare list prices get surprised.

Amenities

What Bexley Residents Actually Use Every Week

The amenity list is long, but these are the pieces buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home's value when it is time to sell.

The Bexley Club

The resort-style heart of the community: a clubhouse with a fitness center and game room, two resort-style pools plus a lap pool and splash zone, and the Twisted Sprocket Café — a bike-shop café that is open to the public.

Trails & 1,200 Acres of Preserve

More than 10 miles of paved multi-use trails through 1,200 acres of preserved Pasco County wilderness, connecting to the Suncoast Trail for longer rides north and south.

The Hub at Bexley

An open-air commercial district at the community entrance, opened in 2022: coffee, dining, retail, fitness, and the "4 and Co." coworking space — plus the Friday Moonlight Market twice a month.

Parks for Every Age

Five themed parks, including Yellow Brick Park and Game On Park, the Barkyard dog park, the Mud, Sweat & Gears BMX park, soccer fields, playgrounds, and outdoor fitness stations.

Schools Inside the Community

Bexley Elementary School sits inside the neighborhood (opened 2017) — many homes are a short walk or bike ride away. Charles S. Rushe Middle and Sunlake High serve the older grades. Verify the assigned school for any exact address before you offer.

Del Webb Bexley — 55+

A gated active-adult section within Bexley for buyers 55 and over, with its own amenities and an HOA that includes cable, internet, and lawn maintenance. A strong option for downsizers who want the Bexley lifestyle without the yard work.

Housing Market

The Bexley Housing Market

Bexley is the premium master-planned end of Land O'Lakes — its median home price runs well above the town as a whole. The figures below are Bexley-specific, from Homes.com's neighborhood comparison as shown in November 2026.

$588,900Median home price, Bexley — November 2026
$560,000Median sale price, Bexley — November 2026, flat year over year
$238Average price per square foot, Bexley — November 2026
$581,950Median single-family home price, Bexley — November 2026
$374,900Median townhome price, Bexley — November 2026
28Active listings in Bexley — November 2026; about 4 months of supply, a balanced market

Source: Homes.com — Land O' Lakes, FL Home Prices vs. Nearby Neighborhoods, figures as shown November 12, 2026. For comparison, Land O'Lakes overall showed a $411,990 median home price and a $399,495 median sale price (+2% year over year) on the same page. Bexley-specific days on market is not published by the major portals — for context, the Land O'Lakes median was 53 days on market (Realtor.com, June 2026), and a Stellar MLS weekly check showed Land O'Lakes homes at a median 40.5 days to contract with a $430,745 median sale price for the week of October 26–November 1, 2026 (bestcallbrad.com, November 2, 2026).

What this means in plain terms: Bexley at $588,900 sits roughly $177,000 above the Land O'Lakes median — you are paying for new construction, amenities, and the school-inside-the-community setup, and the market prices it that way. Flat year-over-year sale prices and about 4 months of supply make this a balanced market: neither a bidding-war market nor a fire sale.

New construction is still part of the competition. Building continues in and around Bexley, so resale sellers compete with a brand-new home down the road. Buyers should compare builder incentives, lot premiums, and upgrade costs against resale value — and sellers should price against the new homes, not just last year's resales.

Buying in Bexley

Buying a Home in Bexley

Bexley rewards buyers who check the full cost picture early. The list price is only part of what a home here costs each month — get the rest of the numbers before you fall in love with a floor plan.

Start Your Bexley Search

Selling in Bexley

Selling a Home in Bexley

Bexley homes sell on the community as much as on the house itself. The listings that move are priced against Bexley — not against Land O'Lakes as a whole — and marketed to the buyer who wants this lifestyle.

Get a Home Value Conversation

Brian's Take

What I Tell Bexley Buyers Before We Tour a Single Home

Most buyers come to Bexley because the community sells itself the minute you drive in — trails, the club, the school right there. My job is to make sure the numbers work as well as the feeling does.

Explore Nearby Areas

Explore Nearby Areas

Bexley is one neighborhood inside Land O'Lakes — compare the wider area before you settle on one community.

Talk to Brian

Buying or Selling in Bexley?

Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Bexley — the HOA and CDD costs, the new-build-versus-resale comparison, and what homes in your section are actually selling for. No pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Bexley, Land O'Lakes, Trinity, Odessa, and the wider Tampa Bay area.

Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]