St. Petersburg · West-Central St. Pete · Tampa Bay, Florida
Solid mid-century homes and no flood-zone worries — Allendale is west-central St. Pete’s affordable, practical neighborhood.
Brian Baker, REALTOR® · Keller Williams St. Pete Realty · FL License #SL3608413
Living in Allendale
Allendale is a residential neighborhood in west-central St. Petersburg, roughly between 38th and 54th Avenues North on the city’s west side. It is a community of 1950s to 1970s block homes — solid, practical, and among the more affordable in the city — with the Tyrone area’s shopping and the Gulf beaches a short drive away.
Solid mid-century homes, inland. Allendale’s housing stock is mostly 1950s to 1970s block homes, many on solid lots. The neighborhood is inland, with generally no flood-zone exposure, which means simpler insurance and a lower monthly number than the waterfront neighborhoods at the same price.
Affordable by St. Pete standards. Allendale is one of the city’s more affordable established neighborhoods, which is why first-time buyers and long-term residents alike watch it. The value is in the bones — solid block construction, a real lot, and a location that works.
West-side location, citywide access. The Tyrone area’s shopping and dining are minutes away, the Gulf beaches are a short drive west, and downtown is about fifteen minutes east. Allendale is a base for the west-side lifestyle, not a destination itself.
The honest trade-off: the homes are 50 to 70 years old, so roof age, electrical, and plumbing drive insurance and renovation costs. Get a real insurance quote during your inspection period, and ask for the age and documentation of the major systems.
Highlights
The pieces of Allendale buyers ask about first — and the ones that show up in a home’s value when it is time to sell.
A west-side neighborhood with generally no flood-zone exposure — simpler insurance and a lower monthly number.
Solid 1950s to 1970s homes, many on solid lots.
One of the city’s more affordable established neighborhoods.
Shopping, dining, and everyday errands in the Tyrone area, minutes away.
The Gulf beaches are a short drive west.
Downtown’s waterfront and Central Avenue are about fifteen minutes east.
Housing Market
No neighborhood-level market figures are published by the major portals for Allendale, so the figures below are the St. Petersburg city-level numbers, clearly labeled. Allendale trades at the more affordable end of the city’s established neighborhoods — ask Brian for the current comparable sales before you price or offer.
No neighborhood-level market figures are published by the major portals for this neighborhood. The figures above are St. Petersburg city-level figures from Realtor.com — St. Petersburg, FL Housing Market, key indicators as of October 2026. For context, Redfin reported a median sale price of $424,748 for the three months ending September 2026, up 6.5% year over year. Neighborhood-level days on market is not published by the major portals — the city-level median was 80 days on market (Realtor.com, October 2026).
What this means in plain terms: Allendale is a value neighborhood — solid mid-century homes at or below the city median, with the insurance advantage of an inland location. The city-level median of $419,950 is a reasonable starting reference here, with condition doing most of the work in the spread.
Condition is the whole spread: renovated and original 1950s to 1970s homes on the same street can sit far apart in price. That spread is the opportunity for buyers who can see past a dated kitchen — and the risk for sellers who price a fixer like a renovation.
Buying in Allendale
Allendale rewards buyers who check the local details early — flood, insurance, roof, and the true monthly cost — not after they are under contract.
Selling in Allendale
In a balanced St. Petersburg market with a city median of 80 days on market, the listings that sell well are priced against today’s competition in their own neighborhood — and presented on what makes that specific home hard to duplicate.
Brian's Take
Allendale is the west side’s practical buy — a solid mid-century home, no flood zone, and the beaches a short drive away. It is where I send first-time buyers who want a real house, not a project they cannot afford.
Explore Nearby Areas
Allendale is one neighborhood inside St. Petersburg — compare the wider city before you settle on one community.
Talk to Brian
Call, text, or send a message and Brian will walk you through the current numbers for Allendale — no pressure, and no obligation. Brian Baker, REALTOR® with Keller Williams St. Pete Realty, serving Allendale, St. Petersburg, Treasure Island, Tampa, and the wider Tampa Bay area.
Phone: 727-605-4433
Email: [email protected]